# Analysis Brief

**Status:** Approved  
**Approved by:** Project owner  
**Date:** 2026-09-20

## Business question

Which character-creation options from the current Player's Handbook are included in SRD 5.2.1, which are absent, and how can VTT creators use that distinction to make more informed product decisions?

## Target audience

Solo developers and small teams building commercial SaaS products for virtual tabletop ecosystems such as D&D Beyond, Roll20, Owlbear Rodeo, and Foundry. They understand the VTT market but need a faster way to evaluate the content boundary between the Player's Handbook and the SRD.

## Decision supported

For each character-creation option, determine whether:

1. Its name has a corresponding match in SRD 5.2.1, allowing the creator to inspect and use the SRD's own licensed material with attribution.
2. No SRD 5.2.1 name match was verified, so another basis should be investigated before non-SRD content is included.
3. The comparison is ambiguous and requires manual review.

## Proof-of-concept scope

### Included

- Base classes
- Subclasses
- Species
- Backgrounds
- Feats
- Spells
- Equipment
- Class-species combination view

### Postponed

- Multiclass combinations
- Legacy 2014 content
- Earlier editions
- Setting-specific material
- Third-party publisher content
- User accounts and saved sessions

## Comparison

The latest Player's Handbook provides the comparison universe. SRD 5.2.1 provides the reusable-content boundary. The analysis will use only the names, categories, and source identity needed for comparison; it will not reproduce non-SRD descriptions, artwork, statistics, or rules text.

## Classification

- **Included in SRD 5.2.1:** The item was verified in the SRD.
- **Not found in SRD 5.2.1:** The item appears in the comparison universe but was not verified in the SRD.
- **Partial support:** Used for combinations in which one component is included and another is absent.
- **Unresolved:** The evidence is ambiguous or requires manual review.

## Required dashboard capabilities

- Search and filter across all in-scope categories.
- Inspect an item's status and supporting evidence.
- Explore the class-species combination matrix.
- View counts and coverage percentages by category.
- Download an AI audit prompt for checking a VTT codebase or database export.
- See clear recommended next steps without presenting legal conclusions.
- Collect anonymous aggregate search analytics.
- Identify popular unsupported and zero-result searches.

## Success metrics

- Every in-scope Player's Handbook item receives a classification.
- Every supported classification has traceable SRD evidence.
- Ambiguous cases are flagged instead of guessed.
- Users can quickly find an item and understand what to do next.
- The downloadable audit prompt produces a structured exception report.
- Repeated analysis produces consistent results from the same inputs.
- Search analytics reveal popular terms, unsupported demand, and unanswered searches.
- No personal information, source code, or database contents are collected through analytics.

## Delivery constraints

- Publishable through GitHub and Netlify.
- Responsive and accessible.
- Transparent, versioned source data.
- Reproducible classification process.
- Anonymous analytics only.
- No account system in the proof of concept.
- No use of non-SRD descriptions, artwork, or rules text.
- Visible attribution, scope, and decision-support caveats.

## AI contribution

Extract, normalize, compare, classify, trace evidence, generate the audit prompt, identify ambiguity, assist with adversarial verification, and help build the dashboard.

## Project-owner contribution

Define the audience and business purpose, approve scope and risk language, review ambiguous classifications, decide what constitutes acceptable due diligence, evaluate usability, and make final publishing decisions.

## Useful-answer standard

A useful result lets a VTT creator find an option, see whether it is included in SRD 5.2.1, inspect the supporting evidence, understand the limitation of that result, and take an appropriate next step.
