# SRD 5.2.1 Comparison Validation

**Comparison:** `data/phb-vs-srd-comparison.json`  
**SRD scope inventory:** `data/srd-5.2.1-comparison-inventory.json`  
**State:** Verified for name coverage, with documented limitations

## Corrected comparison results

| Category | Player's Handbook | Name matched in SRD 5.2.1 | No SRD name match |
|---|---:|---:|---:|
| Classes | 12 | 12 | 0 |
| Subclasses | 48 | 12 | 36 |
| Species | 10 | 9 | 1 |
| Backgrounds | 16 | 4 | 12 |
| Feats | 75 | 17 | 58 |
| Spells | 391 | 339 | 52 |
| Named nonmagical equipment | 206 | 206 | 0 |
| **Total** | **758** | **599** | **159** |

## Corrections made during Verify

1. Removed `Energy Cell` and `Spiked Armor`. Both came from the Basic Rules index and lacked Player's Handbook filter evidence. The PHB manifest changed from 760 to 758 records.
2. Replaced `srd_supported` with `matched_in_srd` and `due_diligence` with `no_srd_name_match`. These labels describe observed coverage rather than legal conclusions.
3. Added an SRD PDF page to all 599 positive matches.
4. Corrected 17 branded Player's Handbook spell names to their renamed SRD counterparts, including `Bigby's Hand` → `Arcane Hand`, `Melf's Acid Arrow` → `Acid Arrow`, and `Tasha's Hideous Laughter` → `Hideous Laughter`.
5. Recorded `Acid Splash` as a manual extraction resolution because the PDF text layer splits its heading, while the rendered SRD page shows the name.
6. Added PDF pages and canonical names for eight equipment word-order or line-break aliases.
7. Changed automatically scraped PHB feat, spell, and equipment records from `visually_checked` to `automated` provenance.
8. Separated D&D Beyond index evidence from the licensed SRD baseline. Positive coverage claims now cite the supplied SRD PDF.

## Evidence method

- Classes, subclasses, species, and backgrounds use the named SRD sections and pages.
- All 17 feat names were located on SRD pages 87–88.
- All 339 spell matches now have a PDF description page. Seventeen use documented renamed equivalents.
- Equipment is limited to the corrected 206-record PHB universe. Each record was checked against a structured line-start entry, table/variant entry, or documented alias on SRD pages 89–101. All 206 have recorded evidence.
- The SRD PDF, rather than the Basic Rules web index, is the licensing baseline for positive results.

## Interpretation boundary

`matched_in_srd` means a corresponding named option was verified in SRD 5.2.1. It does not license Player's Handbook wording, mechanics, artwork, branding, or an entire implementation. A creator must rely on the material actually contained in the SRD and satisfy CC BY 4.0.

`no_srd_name_match` means no corresponding named option was verified under this method. It does not prove that every use is unlawful. Other possible bases—such as SRD 5.1, separate permission, original material, nominative reference, or other applicable rights—are outside this comparison.

## Residual limitations

- D&D Beyond does not publish a single official total for the approved equipment subset. Equipment membership uses a documented union with item-level exclusions.
- Equipment evidence confirms name presence within the SRD equipment section; it does not compare every mechanical field between the PHB and SRD versions.
- The dataset evaluates current PHB names against SRD 5.2.1 only.
- Legal and platform-policy compliance remain outside the analysis.
