# Adversarial Verification Report

**Project:** D&D SRD Coverage Dashboard  
**Stage:** Verify  
**Status:** Complete with corrections and limitations  
**Review date:** September 20, 2026

## Review design

Three independent agents reviewed the work without editing the original deliverables: a source reviewer, a code reviewer, and an interpretation reviewer. Each was instructed to try to disprove the material claims. The primary agent reproduced their findings, corrected the data, and reran structural validation.

## Claim matrix

| Material claim | Adversarial result | Decision |
|---|---|---|
| The PHB comparison universe contains 760 records | **Disproved** | Corrected to 758 after removing two Basic-Rules-only equipment records |
| The universe contains 208 approved equipment records | **Disproved** | Corrected to 206 |
| 206 of 208 equipment records match the SRD | **Disproved as framed** | Corrected to 206 of 206 within the corrected PHB universe |
| All 12 PHB classes have corresponding SRD names | Upheld | 12 matched |
| 12 of 48 PHB subclasses have corresponding SRD names | Upheld | 12 matched; 36 unmatched |
| 9 of 10 PHB species have corresponding SRD names | Upheld | 9 matched; Aasimar unmatched |
| 4 of 16 PHB backgrounds have corresponding SRD names | Upheld | 4 matched; 12 unmatched |
| 17 of 75 PHB feats have corresponding SRD names | Upheld with stronger evidence | All 17 located on SRD pages 87–88 |
| 339 of 391 PHB spells have SRD counterparts | Upheld with corrections | 17 branded PHB names map to renamed SRD equivalents; every positive now has a PDF page |
| A matching name means the PHB option is safe to use | **Rejected** | A match establishes source coverage only; reuse must come from SRD content |
| `srd_supported` is an appropriate public label | **Rejected** | Replaced with `matched_in_srd` / “Name matched in SRD 5.2.1” |
| `due_diligence` is a sufficiently factual negative label | **Rejected** | Replaced with `no_srd_name_match` / “No SRD 5.2.1 name match — review needed” |

## High-severity findings and corrections

### Equipment universe contamination

`Energy Cell` and `Spiked Armor` entered through the D&D Beyond Basic Rules filter, not the Player's Handbook filter. The generator then labeled them as PHB records. Both were removed. This changed the comparison universe from 760 to 758 records and removed the only two alleged equipment gaps.

### Name matching was interpreted too broadly

The original label could imply that corresponding Player's Handbook text or mechanics were licensed. The evidence establishes only that a corresponding named option occurs in the SRD. Public wording and status codes were narrowed accordingly.

### Web-index evidence was conflated with licensed-source evidence

D&D Beyond indexes remain useful for constructing and checking the comparison universe. Positive licensing-baseline claims now point to the supplied SRD 5.2.1 PDF. Basic Rules index results are not presented as reusable licensed content.

### Renamed spells were hidden by the web index

Direct PDF reconciliation found seventeen branded PHB spell names that use different SRD names. These are now explicit `approved_alias` records with both names and an SRD page. `Acid Splash` required a separate manual resolution because of a broken PDF text heading.

### Equipment substring matching was too permissive

The first matcher accepted a name anywhere in the equipment chapter, which could confuse an incidental mention with a listed item. It was replaced with structured line-start checks plus individually documented table, variant, and alias resolutions. All 206 retained equipment records now have structured evidence and an SRD page.

## Other corrections

- Automated PHB index records now use `automated` provenance instead of `visually_checked`.
- Eight equipment aliases now have PDF pages and canonical names.
- The stale classes/species-only source description was replaced with the complete scope and factual status definitions.
- The attribution document contains the SRD-requested attribution statement, modification note, scope notice, and separate non-endorsement language.
- Stale notes implying that the SRD comparison was still pending were removed from generated records.

## Reproduced final controls

- 758 comparison records and 758 unique IDs.
- 599 `matched_in_srd` records.
- 159 `no_srd_name_match` records.
- Zero null SRD assertions.
- All 599 positive matches contain an SRD PDF page.
- All 206 equipment matches passed the structured-entry or documented-manual-resolution check.
- 26 documented manual resolutions: 17 renamed spells, `Acid Splash`, and 8 equipment variants.
- Category arithmetic reconciles to the full 758-record universe.

## Residual limitations

The verification supports a **name-coverage dashboard**. It does not establish that a product, implementation, copied passage, rules expression, artwork, logo, product name, contract, platform integration, or marketing claim is legally permitted. Equipment has no single published official PHB subset total and remains the least certain category. The dashboard must avoid “safe,” “legal,” “illegal,” and “infringing” classifications.

## Verification decision

The corrected dataset **passes Verify for the stated purpose of comparing current Player's Handbook option names with SRD 5.2.1 names**. It does not pass as a legal-compliance determination. The approved public labels are:

- **Name matched in SRD 5.2.1**
- **No SRD 5.2.1 name match — review needed**
- **Ambiguous — manual review required**
